
The construction boom in the Southwest has led to a rise in the use of untrained and unskilled labor… leading to shoddy workmanship, code violations and poor building practices… who's responsible?
Your builder is responsible for the cost to remedy defects from construction of your home, condo, or office condo.
For over ten years, DCLS has been providing experienced, reliable and committed legal resources to homeowners and homeowner associations in construction defect litigation. A review of our Verdicts and Settlements below highlights recent successes for homeowners and their associations.
Developer: Confidential
195 Single Family Homes
The homes in this community suffered from damage to their foundations and slab systems and also had serious cracking in their drywall and stucco systems.
Settlement/Judgment - $1,938,000.00
Duration - 38 months
Developer: Confidential
589 Single Family Homes (certified class action)
This matter was certified as a class action in August 2005. The homes in this community suffered from damage to their foundation and slab systems that caused cracking in the slabs and interior drywall.
Settlement/Judgment - $2,725,000.00
Duration - 22 months
Developer: Confidential
261 Single Family Homes (certified class action)
This matter was certified as a class action in May 2004. The homes in this community suffered from damage to their foundations and slab systems and also had serious cracking in their drywall and stucco systems due to water intrusion through the roofs and windows.
Settlement/Judgment - $2,600,000.00
Duration - 28 months
Developer: Confidential
345 Single Family Homes (certified class action)
This matter was certified as a class action in April 2004. The homes in this community suffered from damage to their foundations and slab systems. They also had defects in the drywall and stucco design resulting from inadequate grading and drainage.
Settlement/Judgment - $2,275,000.00
Duration - 36 months
Developer: Confidential
79 Single Family Homes (certified class action)
This matter was certified as a class action in December 2004. The homes in this community had water intrusion at the roofs and windows, as well as problems with their foundations and slabs resulting in problems with the drywall and stucco systems.
Settlement/Judgment - $760,000.00
Duration - 36 months
Developers: Confidential
5 Single Family Homes
These homes had water intrusion at the roofs and windows, as well as problems with their foundations and slabs resulting in problems with the drywall and stucco systems.
Settlement/Judgment - confidential
Duration - 11 months
Developer: Hughes Development
263 unit condominium complex
This condominium development encountered problems with water intrusion at roofs, windows and doors, stucco and deck systems, as well as poor or inadequate grading and drainage in the common areas.
Settlement/Judgment - $2,420,000.00 ($1,520,000.00 cash; $900,000.00 in repairs)
Duration - 19 months
Developer: Canyon Mesa III
20 unit condominium complex
This condominium development encountered problems with water intrusion at roofs, stucco and deck systems, as well as poor or inadequate grading and drainage in the common areas.
Settlement/Judgment - $225,000 plus repairs
Duration - 17 months
Developer: PAW III
264 units of converted apartments into condominiums
This condominium development encountered problems with water intrusion at roofs, stucco and deck systems.
Settlement/Judgment - $50,000 plus repairs
Duration - 9 months
Developer: Confidential
64 Single Family Homes
The homes in this matter had problems with faulty roof tiles and poor stucco.
Settlement/Judgment - $241,000.00
Duration - 14 months
Developer: Jackson Properties
19 Single Family Homes
The homes in this development had problems with the foundations and slabs, as well as problems with the drywall and stucco systems and water intrusion at the roofs, windows and doors.
Settlement/Judgment - $670,000.00
Duration - 32 months
Developer: Greystone
41 Single Family Homes
These homes had problems with inadequate draining and grading resulting in problems with their foundation and slab systems. As an additional result, there were problems with the framing, drywall and stucco systems, as well as problems with the roofs and windows.
Settlement/Judgment - $861,000.00
Duration - 18 months
Developer: Avian Homes, LLC
188 unit Condominium complex
This condominium development encountered problems with water intrusion at roofs, stucco and deck systems, as well as inadequate grading and drainage in the common areas of the community.Settlement/Judgment - $1,132,000.00 (partial)
Duration - 22 months
Developer: Beazer / Del Mar
2 Single Family Homes
These homes had problems with cracking in the drywall, stucco and foundation systems, as well as water intrusion at the roofs and windows.
Settlement/Judgment - $50,000.00
Duration - 34 months
Developer: SRA/Westmark
48 Single family homes
These homes had problems with cracking in the drywall, stucco and foundation systems, as well as water intrusion at the roofs and windows.
Settlement/Judgment - $1,000,000.00
Duration - 33 months
Developer: Providence Homes
49 Single family homes
These homes had problems with cracking in the drywall, stucco and foundation systems, as well as water intrusion at the roofs and windows.
Settlement/Judgment - $1,300,000.00
Duration - 35 months
Developer: Estes Homes
59 Single Family Homes
The homes experienced water intrusion, cracking in the stucco and slabs, as well as poor drainage.
Settlement/Judgment - $1,250,000.00
Duration - 24 months
Developer: Fulton Homes
270 Single Family Home certified class action
This matter was certified as a class action in April 2003. The community as a whole suffered from problems with stucco and foundation systems, as well as water intrusion in the roof, window and door systems.
Settlement/Judgment - $4,790,000.00
Duration - 44 months
Developer: Confidential
39 Single Family Homes
The homes experienced problems with the roof systems.
Settlement/Judgment - $70,000.00
Duration - 27 months
Developer: Brown Family Communities
61 Single Family Home certified class action
This matter was certified as a class action in April 2003. The community as a whole suffered from problems with the grading and foundation systems.
Settlement/Judgment - $1,300,000.00
Duration - 36 months
Developer: Confidential
38 Single Family Homes
The homes experienced problems with the roof and window systems, as well as poor drainage.
Settlement/Judgment - $285,000.00
Duration - 13 months
Developer: Four Peaks AZ, LLC
31 Unit Condominium Complex
This condominium development encountered problems with water intrusion at roofs, stucco and deck systems.
Settlement/Judgment - $357,000.00
Duration - 14 months
Developer: Confidential
88 Unit Condominium Complex
This condominium development experienced problems with water intrusion at the windows, decks and roof systems, as well as cracking in the stucco and foundation systems.
Settlement/Judgment - $1,320,000.00
Duration - 20 months
Developer: Confidential
32 Unit Condominium complex
This condominium development experienced problems with water intrusion, cracking in the stucco and foundation systems, as well as problems with the roof systems.
Settlement/Judgment - $416,000.00
Duration - 24 months
Developer: Confidential
52 unit condominium complex
This development experienced problems with water intrusion at the windows, decks, and roof systems.
Settlement/Judgment - $650,000.00
Duration - 20 months
Developer: Confidential
132 unit condominium complex
This development experienced problems with water intrusion, cracking in the stucco and foundation system, as well drainage issues.
Settlement/Judgment - $1,650,000.00
Duration - 27 months
Developer: Sun Tech Development
108 unit condominium complex
This development experienced problems with water intrusion at windows, decks and roof systems, as well as other problems. A partial settlement with the developer, general contractor and certain subcontractors, which includes a stipulated judgment, was achieved in 19 months.
Settlement/Judgment - $2,096,330.00
Duration - 13 months
Developer: Par Pueblo
84 unit condominium complex
This development experienced problems with water proofing, mechanical and electrical defects.
Settlement/Judgment - $1,700,000.00
Duration - 10 months
Developer: Cavalier Development
40 unit condominium complex
This development experienced problems with poor stucco, window, roof and deck leaks, as well as other defects.
Settlement/Judgment - $836,500.00
Duration - 10 months
Developer: The Lakes, LP/Prime Construction
126 unit Townhouse complex
This development was plagued with leaks at roofs, windows, and balcony decks. A partial settlement with the developer and certain subcontractors, which includes a stipulated judgment, was achieved in less than two years.
Settlement/Judgment - $8,500,000.00
Duration - 30 months
Developer: Cavalier Developments
107 Unit condominium complex
This development experienced problems with leaks at windows, roofs and decks, as well as other defects.
Settlement/Judgment - $2,720,000.00
Duration - 14 months
Developer: Mirage Homes
52 Unit condominium complex
This development in experienced problems with leaking windows, roofs and decks along with various other issues.
Settlement/Judgment - $884,000.00
Duration - 10 months
Developer: Hancock Communities
This case involved deficiencies in the common area streets and gutters and retention basins.
Settlement/Judgment - $290,001.00
Duration - 18 months
Developer: Highland Homes
32 unit condominium complex
This development encountered water intrusion problems with the windows/stucco and roof systems.
Settlement/Judgment - $483,980.00
Duration - 23 months
Developer: Confidential
32 unit condominium complex
This development encountered water intrusion at the windows and roof systems.
Settlement/Judgment - $600,000.00
Duration - 18 months
Developer: F- Square Corporation
36 unit condominium complex
This complex encountered problems with water intrusion at roofs, stucco and deck systems.
Settlement/Judgment - $807,250.00
Duration - 18 months
Developer: Confidential
74 unit condominium complex
This complex experienced water intrusion problems at windows and decks.
Settlement/Judgment - $1,150,000.00
Duration - 16 months
Developer: Andrew Bros. Construction
48 unit condominium complex
This complex experienced water intrusion problems at windows and roofs.
Settlement/Judgment - $ 800,000.00
Duration - 19 months
Developer: Foothill Vista
38 unit condominium complex
This complex experienced problems with various construction defects.
Settlement/Judgment - $629,450.00
Duration - 20 months
Developer: Towne Development
This condominium development in Scottsdale, Arizona experienced problems with fire- stopping, water-proofing, electrical and other defects.
Settlement/Judgment - $1,200,000.00 (approximately) worth of repairs
Duration - 6 months
Developer: Confidential
This 100+ unit development located in Newport Coast, California had water intrusion problems at roof to wall transitions and pot shelf windows. The case was settled following extensive mediation sessions.
Settlement/Judgment - $1,246,626.00
Duration - 20 months
Developer: KB Homes
This 75 unit townhome development located in Anaheim, California, had deteriorating siding and miscellaneous roof leaks. A joint Plaintiff-Defense investigation was conducted and the case settled upon initial mediation.
Settlement/Judgment - $800,000.00
Duration - 12 months
Developer: Sea Country Homes
This 175 unit development located in Rancho Santa Marguerita, California, suffered from under slab plumbing leaks and miscellaneous roof leaks. The case was successfully mediated to resolution without the need for costly depositions.
Settlement/Judgment - $2,200,000.00
Duration - 18 months
Developer: Bulmer Development
This 70 unit development located in Ojai, California, had site drainage issues, rusted wrought iron fencing and miscellaneous roof leaks. The case was resolved in mediation.
Settlement/Judgment - $650,000.00
Duration - 16 months
Developer: Confidential
This 19 unit development located in Pomona experienced leaks and associated damage at roofs, windows and plumbing systems.
Settlement/Judgment - $522,500.00
Duration - 13 months
Reconstruction General Contractor: New Dawn Builders
This 664 unit condominium complex project encountered defective reconstruction work at wall to roof lines, leading to extensive water intrusion into unit interiors.
Settlement/Judgment - $957,500.00
Duration - 24 months
Developer: Deer Cove Village, LLP
This 76 unit complex located in Thousand Oaks, encountered water intrusion at roofs, windows and sliding glass doors. Despite facing statute of limitations defenses, Dicks & Coglianese was able to successfully resolve this case in just over one year.
Settlement/Judgment - $1,317,500.00
Duration - 24 months
Developer: Confidential
This 163 unit complex located in Aliso Viejo, encountered water intrusion at roofs, windows and sliding glass doors. Despite facing statute of limitations defenses, Dicks & Coglianese was able to successfully resolve this case in just over one year.
Settlement/Judgment - $2,337,000.00
Duration - 14 months
Developer(s): Confidential
This 243 unit condominium development built by two developers and located in Aliso Viejo, experienced a variety of construction defects, including improperly installed bath tubs and leaks at windows and roofs.
Settlement - $4,100,000.00
Duration - 14 months
Developer(s): MKK/Casa Marina Townhomes
This 95 unit complex located in Oxnard had a significant amount of work performed, however was still plagued by balcony deck leaks. Although the evidence was complicated by the fact that reconstruction was previously performed, Dicks & Coglianese recovered funds sufficient to repair the ongoing problems.
Settlement - $1,000,000.00 (approx)
Duration - 24 months
Developer: Confidential
This condominium project located in Tustin was plagued by window leaks and plumbing leaks.
Settlement/Judgment - $2,800,000.00
Duration - 18 months
Developer(s): Confidential
This case involved improper construction of rear-yard walls throughout a master-planned community in Laguna Hills. Dicks & Coglianese replaced prior counsel and represented the association in this claim, as well as in several claims brought by the individual homeowners, having obtained settlements in all of the actions.
Settlement - $1,400,000 (gross)
Duration - 28 months (approx.)
Developer(s): Western Pacific Housing
This 212 unit condominium development located in Trabuco Canyon, experienced limited deficiencies with site drainage and area separation walls in attics, as well as isolated window leaks.
Settlement - $1,400,000.00
Duration - 18 months
Developer: Lennar
This case involved deficiently designed and constructed streets throughout a master-planned community located in Coto De Caza. Dicks & Coglianese stepped in and replaced the AssociationŐs original counsel, and achieved this settlement within eleven (11) months.
Settlement - $1,573,000.00
Duration - 11 months
Developer: J.M. Peters, Inc.
This 132 townhome development located in Rancho Santa Margarita experienced several construction defects including water intrusion through roofs and windows, as well as cracked stucco.
Settlement - $2,575,000.00
Duration - 16 months
Developer: Beazer Homes and Watt Homes
This 423-unit condominium development which is located in Orange experienced a variety of construction defects including water intrusion problems with the decks, windows, doors, and roofs and improper site drainage.
Settlement - $6,300,000.00
Duration - 18 months
Developer: Kaufman and Broad
Dicks & Coglianese was retained to negotiate a settlement for 49 decks and stairs systems within the community that were suffering from water intrusion.
Partial Settlement - $500,000.00
Developer(s): Calprop Corp., Ryland Homes
This 80 unit townhome development was constructed by two developers in the early 1990Ős and is located in Glendale experienced defects including water intrusion through roofs and windows, as well as cracked stucco.
Settlement - $1,400,000.00
Duration - 14 months
Developer(s): Domain Developers, Inc. and Buie Communities
This 176-unit common interest development which is located in Rancho Niguel suffered from a variety of construction defects including, leaky decks and windows, and roofing problems. Dicks & Coglianese stepped in and replaced Costa BravaŐs original counsel and achieved this result within approximately sixteen months.
Settlement - $2,300,000.00
Duration - 16 months
Developer: Confidential
This 181-unit project located in Aliso Viejo experienced a variety of construction defects including, roofing problems, decks and windows. Dicks & Coglianese was able to achieve a substantial recovery for the majority of plaintiffŐs claimed damages in an extraordinarily short time frame.
Partial Settlement - $3,139,500.00
Duration - 9 months
Developer: Confidential
This 200-unit condominium project which is located in Rancho Santa Margarita experienced significant water intrusion at the decks, windows and roofs. Additional problems included, stained and spalled stucco, along with structural and mechanical issues. Dicks & Coglianese was able to achieve a substantial recovery for the majority of plaintiffŐs claimed damages in an extraordinarily short time frame.
Partial Settlement - $2,900,000.00
Duration - 8 months
Developer: Kaufman and Broad
This 74-unit Anaheim association suffered from a variety of construction defects including water intrusion problems with the roofs and windows and concrete driveway failures.
Settlement - $1,150,000.00
Duration - 16 months
Developer: Wilma Pacific
This 67-unit condominium development experienced water intrusion through roofs, windows and chimneys. Numerous obstacles to the claim existed, including a long-since bankrupt developer, statute of limitations problems, and past partial settlements. Nonetheless, Dicks & Coglianese was able to obtain this substantial recovery for the association.
Settlement - $543,750.00
Duration - 18 months
Developer: Bramalea California, Inc.
This 149-unit townhome project in Mission Viejo faced problems which included leaks at roofs, windows and decks. Numerous difficulties/impediments existed in prosecuting this claim, including a bankrupt developer and a complete lack of project records, making identification of all of the involved subcontractors impossible. These factors made the success achieved on behalf of the association that much more remarkable.
Settlement - $2,100,000.00
Duration - 36 months
Developer: Confidential
This 125-unit project located in Anaheim experienced water intrusion problems to the windows, roofs and decks. Dicks & Coglianese stepped in and replaced HorizonŐs original counsel and achieved this result within approximately fifteen months.
Settlement - $2,556,500.00
Duration - 15 months
Developer: Warmington Homes
This 117-unit project located in Oxnard experienced water intrusion problems to the windows, roofs and decks. Dicks & Coglianese stepped in and secured a settlement of nearly five times that offered by the Developer after a one-year Calderon process.
Settlement - $2,300,000.00
Duration - 14 months
Developer: Newcomb/Anden Development
This 35-unit project located in Newport Beach experienced water intrusion problems to the decks, windows and parking garage.
Settlement - $1,675,000.00
Duration - 15 months
Developer: Confidential
This 132-unit condominium project located in Aliso Viejo was plagued by water intrusion through roofs, windows and potshelves, as well as stained and cracked stucco.
Settlement - $2,710,000.00
Duration - 17 months
Developer: Confidential
This 120-unit condominium project located in Rancho Santa Margarita experienced multiple defects including water intrusion, improperly installed plumbing systems, failed site draining, and cracked stucco and slabs.
Settlement - $2,350,000.00
Duration - 22 months
Developer: S&S Construction
This 243-unit complex located in Laguna Niguel experienced a variety of construction defects including roof, window and deck leaks, improper framing and improperly installed, deteriorating asphalt pavement.
Settlement - $4,130,000.00
Duration - 18 months
Developer: Confidential
This 396-unit project located in Irvine experienced numerous defects including roof, window and balcony deck leaks. Additional problems included deteriorating stair stringers and landings, among other items.
Settlement - $6,850,000.00
Duration - 13 months
Developer: Confidential
This 296-unit project located in Rancho Santa Margarita experienced numerous defects including roof, window and balcony deck leaks. Additional problems include deteriorating stair stringers and landings, among other items.
Settlement - $7,757,500.00
Duration - 14 months
Developer: E & E Development and Investment Corporation
This 216-unit condominium project located in Sherman Oaks, experienced defects involving roofs; windows; structural; plumbing/mechanical; civil/drainage; acoustical and electrical. This Association also endured damages inflicted by the 1994 Northridge Earthquake.
Settlement - $5,014,000.00
Developer: ISCO Industries/Prime West, Inc.
This 60-unit project located in Huntington Park experienced defects involving roof leaks, window leaks, and severely deteriorated decks, among other items. Final resolution was obtained within 14 months of filing of the complaint.
Settlement - $1,709,500.00
Developer: Warmington Homes/Mercury Savings
This 112-unit project located in Lake Forest experienced defects involving roofs, decks, windows, and fireplaces.
Settlement - $4,000,000.00
Developer: Emerald Investments, Inc.
This 124-unit project located in Long Beach, experienced defects involving decks, framing, windows, mechanical and electrical systems.
Settlement - $3,100,000.00
Developer: Baywood Development Group, Inc.
This 150-unit condominium project located in Rancho Santa Margarita, experienced defects involving roof, deck and window leaks; along with structural, electrical and plumbing/mechanical defects.
Settlement - $3,115,000.00
Developer: Gramercy Properties and Accurmac Development
This 90-unit condominium project located in Los Angeles, experienced defects involving roofs, windows and miscellaneous architectural, plumbing and structural items.
Settlement - $1,507,000.00
Developer: Warmington Homes
These 39 Single Family Homes located in Corona experienced roof and window leaks. Dicks & Coglianese resolved this matter within one year of assuming representation of plaintiffs from prior counsel.
Settlement - $ 750,000.00
Developer: Wilma Pacific Inc.
This 180-unit condominium project located in Thousand Oaks, experienced defects involving premature deterioration of the stairs, landings, and private balconies. This Association faced extreme problems with the three year (3) statute of limitations defense, and a bankrupt developer.
Partial Settlement - $1,217,000.00
Judgment - $1,400,000.00+
Developer: McKellar/Ahmanson Development, Inc.
This 266-unit condominium project located in Rancho Niguel, experienced defects involving roofs, windows, asphalt streets and structural framing.
Partial Settlement/Verdict - $4,500,000.00+
Developer: D.T. Smith, Inc.
This 54-unit project located in Rancho Santa Margarita, experienced defects involving roof and deck leaks along with electrical defects.
Settlement - $730,000.00
Developer: North Oaks Properties LTD.
This 112-unit condominium project located in Thousand Oaks, experienced construction defects involving leakage at decks, stairs, balconies, roofs, and windows. In addition, the Association faced a significant three-year statute of limitations defense.
Settlement - $3,400,000.00